Table 2. Changes in pH values and color values of cooked patties formulated with different amounts of cacao nip extracts (CEs) during cold storage (4°C)
Traits | Storage periods (d) | CON | Treatment1) |
CE-0.025 | CE-0.05 | CE-0.075 | CE-0.1 | ASC-0.1 |
pH | 0 | 5.79±0.01Da | 5.78±0.01Bab | 5.76±0.02Cb | 5.74±0.01Dc | 5.73±0.02Cc | 5.63±0.03Dd |
3 | 5.84±0.01Ca | 5.81±0.01Bb | 5.80±0.01Bb | 5.77±0.01Cc | 5.77±0.02Bc | 5.72±0.02Cd |
7 | 5.84±0.01BCa | 5.82±0.01Bab | 5.81±0.01Bbc | 5.80±0.03Bcd | 5.78±0.03Bd | 5.74±0.01BCe |
10 | 5.86±0.03ABa | 5.85±0.01Aa | 5.83±0.01Ab | 5.81±0.02ABb | 5.78±0.01Bc | 5.75±0.01Bd |
15 | 5.87±0.01Aa | 5.85±0.02Aab | 5.84±0.01Abc | 5.83±0.02Ac | 5.81±0.02Ad | 5.78±0.02Ae |
CIE L* | 0 | 66.45±0.75Ca | 65.24±0.52Bb | 64.67±1.15bc | 62.97±1.29Bc | 58.84±1.06Db | 67.78±0.86a |
3 | 66.82±0.44Cab | 66.34±1.57ABab | 65.33±1.19bc | 63.19±0.62ABc | 60.20±2.36ABd | 68.49±1.34a |
7 | 67.35±0.86BCa | 66.23±1.43ABa | 65.51±0.62ab | 62.76±2.38Bbc | 61.70±1.86Ac | 67.96±1.17a |
10 | 68.74±1.07ABa | 66.68±0.64ABb | 64.55±0.60c | 63.92±1.11ABc | 61.73±0.67Ad | 69.48±0.28a |
15 | 69.63±1.54Aa | 67.98±1.02Aa | 65.35±0.83b | 65.43±0.75Ab | 60.93±0.48ABd | 68.46±0.87a |
CIE a* | 0 | 4.61±0.37Ac | 4.89±0.41Ac | 5.55±0.13Ab | 5.76±0.21ab | 6.03±0.19Aa | 5.45±0.19Ab |
3 | 4.02±0.18Bb | 4.56±0.21Ac | 4.92±0.16Bb | 5.62±0.09b | 6.05±0.17Aa | 5.22±0.32ABbc |
7 | 3.59±0.33Bc | 3.62±0.27BCc | 4.47±0.13BCb | 5.53±0.36ab | 5.81±0.26Aba | 5.19±0.22ABb |
10 | 2.76±0.19Cd | 3.24±0.45BCc | 4.14±0.15Cb | 5.39±0.26a | 5.62±0.35Ba | 5.18±0.28ABa |
15 | 2.26±0.45Cd | 2.98±0.53Cc | 3.23±0.66Dc | 5.19±0.43a | 5.61±0.30Ba | 4.85±0.22Ba |
CIE b* | 0 | 14.42±0.54BCa | 13.72±0.39a | 13.60±0.27ABb | 13.99±0.57Ba | 13.83±0.45ABa | 11.19±0.70Cb |
3 | 14.04±0.86Ca | 13.64±0.21a | 14.00±0.25Aab | 12.44±0.90Bbc | 12.71±1.12Babc | 11.97±0.58Cc |
7 | 15.07±0.27BCa | 14.35±0.41ab | 14.73±0.63Aa | 12.21±0.51Bc | 12.74±0.43Bc | 13.55±0.33Bb |
10 | 15.23±0.23Aba | 14.11±0.28b | 14.06±0.43Ab | 13.79±0.76Ab | 12.90±0.30ABc | 13.86±0.77ABb |
15 | 15.74±0.79Aa | 14.23±0.86bc | 14.74±0.92Abc | 13.01±0.64ABc | 13.92±0.36Abc | 14.75±0.49Aab |
The mixing ratios of the ingredients are shown in Table 1.
Means within a column with different letters are significantly different (p<0.05).
Means within a row with different letters are significantly different (p<0.05).